Josh Cribbs Thursday

It may be a bit out of the ordinary for this site, but I thought I would devote today’s post exclusively to one player.

I’m getting the uncomfortable feeling that this Sunday could be the last home game for Browns’ veteran Josh Cribbs. Cribbs’ unsettled contract situation, combined with the league’s de-emphasis on kickoff returns, joined with the current coaching staff’s unwillingness or inability to utilize Cribbs in a more effective manner could all contribute to the newest Browns’ front office management deciding to cut ties with the team’s second-longest tenured player.

While it’s become difficult to be a genuine fan – especially given how exposed today’s NFL players are – Cribbs is an extraordinarily easy choice. It’s ridiculously easy for me to suspend reality and root for Cribbs as if I were a kid and he were a part of the 1985 Browns. As a sometimes too cynical adult, I’ve found that there is still something magic about Cribbs barreling down the sideline on a return or covering a kickoff like he was trying to make a scout team. Perhaps the manner in which Cribbs both entered the league and has conducted himself throughout his career helps most Browns’ fans identify with him. If you only strip away the enormous physical talents and incredible toughness, Cribbs really isn’t that much different from most of the fans who have supported him for years.

Much like a Browns’ fan who continues to weather constant front office, coaching, personnel changes and perpetual losing, Cribbs is a rarity in that he is an actual Browns’ veteran. To stick around for eight seasons in Cleveland among all the constant turnover is perhaps the most impressive stat one can find. Of course, the 13,000 all-purpose yards and 8 kickoff return touchdowns are technically more meaningful. However, Cribbs has always been the hardest working and most exciting Browns’ player of the past decade – along with being a player whose value has been increasingly difficult to define.

On the surface, one could say that Cribbs is basically “just” a Special Teams player. With the exception of a slight impact in 2011 as a wide receiver, Cribbs has made his living returning and covering kickoffs. In fact, without Brian Daboll, Cribbs likely would not have been used on offense at all during his Browns’ tenure. To this point, thousands of words can be devoted to how the Browns have badly underutilized Cribbs. Beyond the gimmicky prowess of the Wildcat formation, it’s easy to think that Cribbs could have been used the way other teams utilize Aaron Hernandez or Percy Harvin.

Of course, the preceding was probably a more valid argument a couple years ago. As the Browns have slowly developed more offensive talent, it seems that Cribbs has quietly disappeared into the background. While the Browns’ offense is pretty far from being anything proficient, it is far advanced from the days when Cribbs was pretty much the ONLY offensive threat on the roster. Add in the league’s de-emphasis on kickoff returns and it seems like Cribbs’ epic quest for a new contract happened decades ago.

In an ideal sense, the current Browns are improving both on and off the field – to the point where the malaise of the past decade plus will be covered by some fresh and more significant memories. As such, any new memories will likely make us forget Cribbs’ contributions over the past 8 years – which is a shame.

I’m never one to tell someone how to feel, but it would be tragic to forget that Cribbs was the ONLY exciting player in Cleveland during a long period of terrible Browns’ football. Perhaps no better example can be found than during the infamous “Staged Walkout” game on a Monday Night in 2009. Part of the concern of participating in the ill-fated walkout was that fans would miss the only chance for real excitement – which was Cribbs returning the opening kickoff.

Who knows what will ultimately happen? Cribbs could easily re-sign with the Browns and finish his career where it started. However, given the swirl of uncertainty that faces the Browns under new management, it’s at least worth savoring what could be a final home Sunday of Cribbs’ memories.

For as long as we are Browns’ fans – and as all know, we’re in this for life – the chances of the Browns ever featuring a player like Cribbs are impossibly slim. While Cribbs may have found the Browns at a most unfortunate time, and may not be remembered as he should, it’s worth stating that Cribbs made Browns’ football worth watching during a really difficult time.

And given how we as Browns fans exclusively cling to and excessively celebrate our past, we probably don’t even realize what we had with Cribbs. Maybe in 20 years when the Browns hold a reunion day, we’ll see a highlight and figure out that Cribbs was an extraordinary player.

For now, let’s just enjoy.

Like This Post? Share It

Comments (11)

  1. Bill Adams

    So when there’s a time to honor a player from the 2000′s in the Ring of Honor, do we choose Cribbs or Phil Dawson?

    • fubar

      Both Dawson and Cribbs deserve their place in the Ring of Honor – they earned it. That a kicker and a punt/kick returner/gunner are the two best Browns players of the 2000′s is a testament to the organization’s utter incompetence during that time. That is a slam on Randy Lerner and his pathetic front office musical-chairs-misfits, but never on the players.

      • Luke, you killed it there. Maybe that’s why it’s such a conflict to obsess over a “kick returner”. It’s sad to diminish Cribbs like that, considering how hard he has played. But at the same time, it’s a testament to how terrible these teams have been.

    • Why would we have to choose? They both are Browns’ Hall of Famers.

  2. Cribbs is my favorite football player ever for his leadership and hard work on the field and all that he does for the Cleveland community off the field. You’re right – we have never utilized him properly. He could easily be a Percy Harvin. But he is still Josh Cribbs and since he was a walk on, he’s been the heart and soul of this team. I would literally be heartbroken to see him leave. I hope more than anything that he retires in brown and orange.

    • Totally agreed. While I know he still has several years left to play – and if it doesn’t work out here, I hope he lands on a winner. But right, it just wouldn’t be right to see him in another uniform.

  3. jimkanicki

    [channeling hannibal lecter dialog]
    hannibal: what is josh cribbs?
    agent starling: a kick returner.

    cribbs is and always been a Football Player in the complete sense of the word. i dont know if it was his choice, coach’s decision, agent’s advice; but i always thought he was miscast/shoe-horned into the ‘underutilized offense weapon’ narrative. i always was more impressed with his consistent record of leading in special teams tackles. when we were in need of physical run-supporting safeties, i dont know why cribbs wasnt injected there. perhaps it’s because im here in patriots-land, but i see belichick throwing troy brown and jason edelman into defense; putting mike vrabel at tight end… the over-arching concept is that Football Players play Football. the Football Team is improved when the best Football Players are on the field.

    regrettably, it appears josh has lost some speed and is type-cast as returner and thus his pigeon-hole is closing. it’s a shame.

    • The biggest shame is how the league has pinpointed kickoffs as some salve for concussions. This has reduced Cribbs’ value. And with Shurmur’s unimaginative offense (look, another end around!), Cribbs is nearly forgotten.

      But you’re right, he is a COMPLETE football player. He is phenomenal on kick coverage and is both a hard runner and tackler. As for the safety idea, I’m guessing that is probably extinguished now – but it would have been interesting to see. I’m not sure if Cribbs was agile enough to cover, but he certainly could hit.

      I still think fondly to Jim Brown channeling the 1960′s by calling Cribbs “transcendent spiritual force.” And while I’m pretty cynical most of the time about comments like that, I believed it with Cribbs for a few years there.

  4. tpostdawg

    Love the clip of his Pittsburgh 100 yarder. That single play makes me smile

    and know that I will never forget Joshua Cribbs. Hope there is a way for him

    play his entire career in the Orange and Brown.

  5. Webmaster Guide…

    I ran into this page accidentally, surprisingly, this is a amazing blog :-). The site owner has carried out a superb job of…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *